PDQIE - PDQ Industrial Electric
Laser and Plasma Cutting
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF LASER VS PLASMA
CUTTING
Advantages of laser cutting over mechanical cutting include easier workholding and reduced
contamination of workpiece (since there is no cutting edge which can become contaminated by the material or
contaminate the material). Precision may be better, since the laser beam does not wear during the process. There is
also a reduced chance of warping the material that is being cut, as laser systems have a small heat-affected zone.
Some materials are also very difficult or impossible to cut by more traditional means.
Laser cutting for metals has the advantages over plasma cutting of being more precise and using
less energy when cutting sheet metal, however, most industrial lasers cannot cut through the greater metal
thickness that plasma can. Newer lasers machines operating at higher power (6000 watts, as contrasted with early
laser cutting machines' 1500 watt ratings) are approaching plasma machines in their ability to cut through thick
materials, but the capital cost of such machines is much higher than that of plasma cutting machines capable of
cutting thick materials like steel plate.
The main disadvantage of laser cutting is the high power consumption. Industrial laser efficiency
may range from 5% to 15%. The power consumption and efficiency of any particular laser will vary depending on
output power and operating parameters. This will depend on type of laser and how well the laser is matched to the
work at hand. The amount of laser cutting power required, known as heat input, for a particular job depends on the
material type, thickness, process (reactive/inert) used, and desired cutting rate.
LASER CUTTING
Laser cutting is a technology that uses a laser to cut materials, and is typically used for
industrial manufacturing applications, but is also starting to be used by schools, small businesses and hobbyists.
Laser cutting works by directing the output of a high-power laser, by computer, at the material to be cut. The
material then either melts, burns, vaporizes away, or is blown away by a jet of gas, leaving an edge with a
high-quality surface finish. Industrial laser cutters are used to cut flat-sheet material as well as structural and
piping materials.
TYPES
A DIFFUSION COOLED RESONATOR There are three main
types of lasers used in laser cutting. The CO2 laser is suited for cutting, boring, and engraving. The neodymium
(Nd) and neodymium yttrium-aluminum-garnet (Nd-YAG) lasers are identical in style and differ only in application.
Nd is used for boring and where high energy but low repetition are required. The Nd-YAG laser is used where very
high power is needed and for boring and engraving. Both CO2 and Nd/ Nd-YAG lasers can be used for welding.
Common variants of CO2 lasers include fast axial flow, slow axial flow, transverse flow, and
slab.
CO2 lasers are commonly "pumped" by passing a current through the gas mix (DC-excited) or using
radio frequency energy (RF-excited). The RF method is newer and has become more popular. Since DC designs require
electrodes inside the cavity, they can encounter electrode erosion and plating of electrode material on glassware
and optics. Since RF resonators have external electrodes they are not prone to those problems.
CO2 lasers are used for industrial cutting of many materials including mild steel, aluminum,
stainless steel, titanium, paper, wax, plastics, wood, and fabrics. YAG lasers are primarily used for cutting and
scribing metals and ceramics.
In addition to the power source, the type of gas flow can affect performance as well. In a fast
axial flow resonator, the mixture of carbon dioxide, helium and nitrogen is circulated at high velocity by a
turbine or blower. Transverse flow lasers circulate the gas mix at a lower velocity, requiring a simpler blower.
Slab or diffusion cooled resonators have a static gas field that requires no pressurization or glassware, leading
to savings on replacement turbines and glassware.
The laser generator and external optics (including the focus lens) require cooling. Depending on
system size and configuration, waste heat may be transferred by a coolant or directly to air. Water is a commonly
used coolant, usually circulated through a chiller or heat transfer system.
Lasing Materials Applications
CO2 Boring
Cutting/Scribing Engraving
Nd High-energy pulses
Low repetition speed (1 kHz)
Boring
Nd-YAG Very high energy pulses
Boring Engraving Trimming
LASER MICROJET A laser microjet is a water-jet
guided laser in which a pulsed laser beam is coupled into a low-pressure water jet. This is used to perform laser
cutting functions while using the water jet to guide the laser beam, much like an optical fiber, through total
internal reflection. The advantages of this are that the water also removes debris and cools the material.
Additional advantages over traditional "dry" laser cutting are high dicing speeds, parallel kerf and
omnidirectional cutting.
PROCESS Generation of the laser beam involves
stimulating a lasing material by electrical discharges or lamps within a closed container. As the lasing material
is stimulated, the beam is reflected internally by means of a partial mirror, until it achieves sufficient energy
to escape as a stream of monochromatic coherent light. Mirrors or fiber optics are typically used to direct the
coherent light to a lens, which focuses the light at the work zone. The narrowest part of the focused beam is
generally less than 0.0125 in (0.3175 mm). in diameter. Depending upon material thickness, kerf widths as small as
0.004 in (0.1016 mm) are possible. In order to be able to start cutting from somewhere else than the edge, a pierce
is done before every cut. Piercing usually involves a high-power pulsed laser beam which slowly (taking around 5–15
seconds for 1/2-inch-thick (13 mm) stainless steel, for example) makes a hole in the material.
There are many different methods in cutting using lasers, with different types used to cut
different material. Some of the methods are vaporization, melt and blow, melt blow and burn, thermal stress
cracking, scribing, cold cutting and burning stabilized laser cutting.
BEAM GEOMETRY Industrial Laser Cutting of Steel
with Cutting Instructions Programmed Through the CNC Interface. The parallel rays of coherent light from the laser
source may be 1/16 inch to 1/2 inch (1.5875 mm to 12.7 mm) in diameter. This beam is normally focused and
intensified by a lens or a mirror to a very small spot of about 0.001 inch (0.0254 mm) to create a very intense
laser beam. Recent investigations reveal that the laser beam has a distinctive polarization. In order to achieve
the smoothest possible finish during contour cutting, the direction of polarization must be rotated as it goes
around the periphery of a contoured workpiece. For sheet metal cutting, the focal length is usually between 1.5
inches and 3 inches (38.1 mm and 76.2 mm)
VAPORIZATION CUTTING In vaporization cutting the
focused beam heats the surface of the material to boiling point and generates a keyhole. The keyhole leads to a
sudden increase in absorptivity quickly deepening the hole. As the hole deepens and the material boils, vapor
generated erodes the molten walls blowing eject out and further enlarging the hole. Non melting material such as
wood, carbon and thermoset plastics are usually cut by this method.
Melt and blowMelt and blow or fusion cutting uses high-pressure gas to blow molten material from
the cutting area, greatly decreasing the power requirement. First the material is heated to melting point then a
gas jet blows the molten material out of the kerf avoiding the need to raise the temperature of the material any
further. Materials cut with this process are usually metals.
Thermal stress crackingBrittle materials are particularly sensitive to thermal fracture, a feature
exploited in thermal stress cracking. A beam is focused on the surface causing localized heating and thermal
expansion. This results in a crack that can then be guided by moving the beam. The crack can be moved in order of
m/s. It is usually used in cutting of glass.
Reactive cuttingAlso called "burning stabilized laser gas cutting", "flame cutting".
Reactive cutting is like oxygen torch cutting but with a laser beam as the ignition source. Mostly
used for cutting carbon steel in thicknesses over 1 mm. This process can be used to cut very thick steel plates
with relatively little laser power.
Tolerances and surface finishNew laser cutters have positioning accuracy of 10 micrometers and
repeatability of 5 micrometers.
Standard roughness Rz increases with the sheet thickness, but decreases with laser power and
cutting speed. When cutting low carbon steel with laser power of 800 W, standard roughness Rz is 10 µm for sheet
thickness of 1 mm, 20 µm for 3 mm, and 25 µm for 6 mm. Rz = 12.528*(S^0.542)/((P^0.528)*(V^0.322)) where: S = steel
sheet thickness in mm; P = laser power in kW (Some new laser cutters have laser power of 4 kW.); V = cutting speed
in meters per minute
This process is capable of holding quite close tolerances, often to within 0.001 inch (0.025 mm)
Part geometry and the mechanical soundness of the machine have much to do with tolerance capabilities. The typical
surface finish resulting from laser beam cutting may range from 125 to 250 micro-inches (0.003 mm to 0.006 mm).
MACHINE CONFIGURATIONS
DUAL PALLET FLYING OPTICS LASER
FLYING OPTICS LASERHEAD There are generally three
different configurations of industrial laser cutting machines: Moving material, Hybrid, and Flying Optics systems.
These refer to the way that the laser beam is moved over the material to be cut or processed. For all of these, the
axes of motion are typically designated X and Y axis. If the cutting head may be controlled, it is designated as
the Z-axis.
Moving material lasers have a stationary cutting head and move the material under it. This method
provides a constant distance from the laser generator to the workpiece and a single point from which to remove
cutting effluent. It requires fewer optics, but requires moving the workpiece. This style machine tends to have the
fewest beam delivery optics, but also tends to be the slowest.
Hybrid lasers provide a table which moves in one axis (usually the X-axis) and move the head along
the shorter (Y) axis. This results in a more constant beam delivery path length than a flying optic machine and may
permit a simpler beam delivery system. This can result in reduced power loss in the delivery system and more
capacity per watt than flying optics machines.
Flying optics lasers feature a stationary table and a cutting head (with laser beam) that moves
over the workpiece in both of the horizontal dimensions. Flying optics cutters keep the workpiece stationary during
processing and often do not require material clamping. The moving mass is constant, so dynamics are not affected by
varying size of the workpiece. Flying optics machines are the fastest type, which is advantageous when cutting
thinner workpieces.
Flying optic machines must use some method to take into account the changing beam length from near
field (close to resonator) cutting to far field (far away from resonator) cutting. Common methods for controlling
this include collimation, adaptive optics or the use of a constant beam length axis.
The above is written about X-Y systems for cutting flat materials. The same discussion applies to
five and six-axis machines, which permit cutting formed workpieces. In addition, there are various methods of
orienting the laser beam to a shaped workpiece, maintaining a proper focus distance and nozzle standoff, etc.
PULSING Pulsed lasers which provide a high-power
burst of energy for a short period are very effective in some laser cutting processes, particularly for piercing,
or when very small holes or very low cutting speeds are required, since if a constant laser beam were used, the
heat could reach the point of melting the whole piece being cut.
Most industrial lasers have the ability to pulse or cut CW (Continuous Wave) under NC (numerical
control) program control.
Double pulse lasers use a series of pulse pairs to improve material removal rate and hole quality.
Essentially, the first pulse removes material from the surface and the second prevents the ejecta from adhering to
the side of the hole or cut.
PLASMA CUTTING
Plasma cutting is a process that is used to cut steel and other metals of different thicknesses (or
sometimes other materials) using a plasma torch. In this process, an inert gas (in some units, compressed air) is
blown at high speed out of a nozzle; at the same time an electrical arc is formed through that gas from the nozzle
to the surface being cut, turning some of that gas to plasma. The plasma is sufficiently hot to melt the metal
being cut and moves sufficiently fast to blow molten metal away from the cut.
PROCESS
The HF Contact type uses a high-frequency, high-voltage spark to ionise the air through the torch head and initiate
an arc. These require the torch to be in contact with the job material when starting, and so are not suitable for
applications involving computer numerical controled (CNC) cutting.
The Pilot Arc type uses a two cycle approach to producing plasma, avoiding the need for initial
contact. First, a high-voltage, low current circuit is used to initialize a very small high-intensity spark within
the torch body, thereby generating a small pocket of plasma gas. This is referred to as the pilot arc. The pilot
arc has a return electrical path built into the torch head. The pilot arc will maintain itself until it is brought
into proximity of the workpiece where it ignites the main plasma cutting arc. Plasma arcs are extremely hot and are
in the range of 25,000 °C (45,000 °F).
Plasma is an effective means of cutting thin and thick materials alike. Hand-held torches can
usually cut up to 2 in (48 mm) thick steel plate, and stronger computer-controlled torches can cut steel up to 6
inches (150 mm) thick. Since plasma cutters produce a very hot and very localized "cone" to cut with, they are
extremely useful for cutting sheet metal in curved or angled shapes.
SAFETY Proper eye protection such as welding
goggles and face shields are needed to prevent eye damage called Arc eye as well as damage from debris.
STARTING METHODS Plasma cutters use a number of
methods to start the arc. In some units, the arc is created by putting the torch in contact with the work piece.
Some cutters use a high voltage, high frequency circuit to start the arc. This method has a number of
disadvantages, including risk of electrocution, difficulty of repair, spark gap maintenance, and the large amount
of radio frequency emissions. Plasma cutters working near sensitive electronics, such as CNC hardware or computers,
start the pilot arc by other means. The nozzle and electrode are in contact. The nozzle is the cathode, and the
electrode is the anode. When the plasma gas begins to flow, the nozzle is blown forward. A third, less common
method is capacitive discharge into the primary circuit via a silicon controlled rectifier.
INVERTER PLASMA CUTTERS Analog plasma cutters,
typically requiring more than 2 kilowatts, use a heavy mains-frequency transformer. Inverter plasma cutters rectify
the mains supply to DC, which is fed into a high-frequency transistor inverter between 10 kHz to about 200 kHz.
Higher switching frequencies give greater efficiencies in the transformer, allowing its size and weight to be
reduced.
The transistors used were initially MOSFETs, but are now increasingly using IGBTs. With paralleled
MOSFETs, if one of the transistors activates prematurely it can lead to a cascading failure of one quarter of the
inverter. A later invention, IGBTs, are not as subject to this failure mode. IGBTs can be generally found in high
current machines where it is not possible to parallel sufficient MOSFET transistors.
The switch mode topology is referred to as a dual transistor off-line forward converter. Although
lighter and more powerful, some inverter plasma cutters, especially those without power factor correction, cannot
be run from a generator (that means manufacturer of the inverter unit forbids doing so; it is only valid for small,
light portable generators). However newer models have internal circuitry that allow units without power factor
correction to run on light power generators.
PLASMA GOUGING Plasma gouging is a related
process, typically performed on the same equipment as plasma cutting. Instead of cutting the material, plasma
gouging uses a different torch configuration (torch nozzles and gas diffusers are usually different), and a longer
torch-to-workpiece distance, to blow away metal. Plasma gouging can be used in a variety of applications, including
removing a weld for rework. The additional sparks generated by the process requires the operator to wear a leather
shield protecting their hand and forearm. Torch leads also can be protected by a leather sheath or heavy
insulation.
CNC CUTTING METHODS Plasma cutters have also been
used in CNC machinery. Manufacturers build CNC cutting tables, some with the cutter built in to the table. The idea
behind CNC tables is to allow a computer to control the torch head making clean sharp cuts. Modern CNC plasma
equipment is capable of multi-axis cutting of thick material, allowing opportunities for complex welding seams on
CNC welding equipment that is not possible otherwise. For thinner material cutting, plasma cutting is being
progressively replaced by laser cutting, due mainly to the laser cutter's superior hole-cutting abilities.
A specialized use of CNC Plasma Cutters has been in the HVAC industry. Software will process
information on ductwork and create flat patterns to be cut on the cutting table by the plasma torch. This
technology has enormously increased productivity within the industry since its introduction in the early 1980s.
In recent years there has been even more development in the area of CNC Plasma Cutting Machinery.
Traditionally the machines' cutting tables were horizontal but now due to further research and development Vertical
CNC Plasma Cutting Machines are available. This advancement provides a machine with a small footprint, increased
flexibility, optimum safety, faster operation.
NEW TECHNOLOGY High performance cutIn the past
decade plasma torch manufacturers have engineered new models with a smaller nozzle and a thinner plasma arc. This
allows near-laser precision on plasma cut edges. Several manufacturers have combined precision CNC control with
these torches to allow fabricators to produce parts that require little or no finishing.
COSTS
Plasma torches were once quite expensive. For this reason they were usually only found in professional welding
shops and very well-stocked private garages and shops. However, modern plasma torches are becoming cheaper, and now
are within the price range of many hobbyists. Older units may be very heavy, but still portable, while some newer
ones with inverter technology weigh only a little, yet equal or exceed the capacities of older ones.
HISTORY Plasma cutting - a technology that grew
out of plasma welding in the 1960s - emerged as a very productive way to cut sheet metal and plate in the 1980s. It
had the advantages over traditional "metal against metal" cutting of producing no metal chips and giving accurate
cuts, and produced a cleaner edge than oxy-fuel cutting. Early plasma cutters were large, somewhat slow and
expensive and, therefore, tended to be dedicated to repeating cutting patterns in a "mass production" mode.
As with other machine tools, CNC (computer numerical control) technology was applied to plasma
cutting machines in the late 1980s into the 1990s, giving plasma cutting machines greater flexibility to cut
diverse shapes "on demand" based on a set of instructions that were programmed into the machine's numerical
control. These CNC plasma cutting machines were, however, generally limited to cutting patterns and parts in flat
sheets of steel, using only two axes of motion (referred to as X Y cutting).
|